You’ve registered to vote, but have you filed your bets?
Prediction Markets, let me guess, the killer app is speculation and gambling?
Well, yes and no. We’ve seen this before. There have been degenerate business cultures early on in the global equities industry; from the first issuance of shares by the Dutch East India Company (VOC) in 1602, to modern entrants like Polymarket into the prediction market space.
It’s election time in the United States and this week millions of Americans will head to the polls and cast their ballots for the candidate of their choice. Most recently, the landscape for legal prediction markets in the United States has changed with the Kalshi case. A U.S. Federal Appeals court in early October upheld a lower court’s order that permitted New York derivatives trading platform KalshiEX LLC to list contracts that allow Americans to bet on election outcomes. And, newcomers like the aforementioned Polymarket (available for non-US citizens) have captured the imagination not only of crypto Twitter, but also the general public as the #1 app in the Apple App Store. But prediction markets aren’t new. And do they really work? Is it that pesky regulatory overhang that’s holding the industry back? Or are prediction markets simply not that interesting to attract massive market participation?
Want to bet that you finish reading this article?
We’ve been here before
The origins of prediction markets, especially for political events, can be traced back to at least the early 19th century in the United States. During this time, betting on presidential elections was a common practice, especially in large cities like New York. The concept was simple: bettors would place wagers on the outcome of elections, with the market reflecting collective expectations about who would win.
By the 1860s, these betting markets were well-established in the U.S. and were often seen as reliable indicators of election outcomes. In fact, election betting markets were more popular in the 19th and early 20th centuries than public opinion polls, which didn’t emerge until the 1930s. At the time, newspapers even reported the odds from these markets as “public opinion.”
The strongest speculation is always founded in at least a kernel of truth – Unknown
The early 20th century saw the continuation of election betting, though it began to decline after World War I. One reason for this was the rise of scientific polling, pioneered by George Gallup (yes, those famous Gallup Polls) in the 1930s. As polling gained legitimacy, the public and media turned more attention to poll results rather than betting odds as a measure of candidate support.
However, informal betting continued, and the concept of using market mechanisms to predict outcomes was kept alive in other forms, notably in the realm of finance, where futures and options markets dealt with similar principles of speculation on future events.
The modern era of prediction markets as we know them began to take shape in the 1980s and 1990s. The Iowa Electronic Markets (IEM), founded in 1988 at the University of Iowa, played a pioneering role. The IEM allowed participants to trade contracts based on political election outcomes, similar to futures contracts in commodities markets.
And, in the United Kingdom, prediction markets have been legal since the early 2000s, with Betfair, one of the world’s largest betting exchanges. Betfair offers markets on sports, politics, and other events, and allows people to place bets directly against each other, creating a high-volume marketplace.
All In
Kalshi, Predictit, Betfair, and Polymarket, the list goes on. And, prediction markets are great indicators of success.
In fact, of the 15 US presidential elections between 1884 and 1940, markets were only ever wrong once. The market knows things.
Prediction markets offer several key advantages that make them an effective tool for forecasting and decision-making. They are often more accurate than traditional methods, thanks to the collective wisdom of diverse participants who have a financial incentive to share truthful and well-researched information. Since these markets are continuously updated in real-time, they reflect the latest developments, allowing for dynamic and timely predictions. The broad range of inputs, from experts to ordinary individuals with unique insights, leads to more robust forecasts, reducing the influence of individual biases or groupthink. Additionally, prediction markets are a cost-effective way to gather information, as they naturally aggregate large amounts of data through active participation.
Prediction markets are pretty versatile, with applications across various domains like politics, sports, and corporate decision-making. In fact, corporations have successfully used them to forecast product success or project outcomes. And the crypto community really loves these markets as transparency and open access encourage engagement, making them a democratic process for predicting future events.
A few stats for the all in crowd:
- Prediction markets are more accurate than traditional polls about 70-90% of the time, especially in political forecasting.
- Corporate prediction markets have a strong track record, with firms like Google reporting 75% accuracy in forecasting internal outcomes.
- Studies of U.S. election prediction markets (like IEM) show them outperforming polls, often by a margin of 20-30%.
Savers, Gamblers, & Sharps
Long prediction markets, short polling! Hold your horses, (especially if you’re making a wager) as there is significant pushback to this excitement. Although we’ve seen a pop in prediction markets recently, these markets are not new and just not that popular from a volume perspective. We often hear a common trope of a phantom regulatory boogeyman. “When regulation eases up, these markets will really take off.” However, critics are quick to point out that these markets are and have been legal around the world for a long time. And there’s just no major interest to participate. To give you an idea on size; Americans legally bet over $330 billion on sports in 2023 alone. This includes activities like betting on football, basketball, and other sports through sportsbooks. The sports gambling industry has massive participation, quick resolutions, and lots of excitement, which attract a huge number of bettors. By contrast, prediction markets are much smaller. For example, during the 2020 U.S. presidential election, an estimated $1 billion was staked across all prediction markets. Even the most popular prediction markets, like those on U.S. elections, don’t come close to the size of sports gambling.
This is because there are essentially 3 groups of investors. Savers, Gamblers, and Sharps. Even though these markets are legal in many places around the world, why don’t we see people using them for all kinds of things, like betting on science or political events in massive volumes? Critics will say that these markets haven’t found the right audience. So, let’s talk about the audience. As we mentioned there are three essential types of investors. First there are the Savers. These are the people who invest in retirement funds or stocks, and aren’t interested in prediction markets because they’re zero-sum games, meaning for every winner, there’s a loser. With traditional investments, you can make money over time, (did someone say compounding?) but prediction markets don’t work like that. Next there’s our familiar Gamblers. This demographic prefer quick, exciting bets like sports games, not slow or niche events like elections. Prediction markets often take a long time to resolve and aren’t as thrilling as betting on sports. And finally, there are Sharps. These are the experts trying to make money by using their knowledge (think quant funds; professionals) and aren’t drawn to prediction markets because there isn’t enough money or activity in them to make it worth their time. Plus they’re competing against other sharps. If it’s just sharps v sharps the competitive advantage is limited. Candidly, that’s what makes equity markets so interesting for them is that they posit they have an advantage over retail investors. Over a long enough time horizon if you’re right 51% of the time, that adds up to big money. But you need to play a lot of games quickly. Prediction markets up to this point have not offered that attraction for sharps.
In short, while prediction markets are cool in theory, they haven’t become big because they don’t attract enough users, and other methods of predicting the future are often more practical and efficient.
What’s Futarchy?
“Crypto is everything you don’t understand about computers, combined with everything you don’t understand about money” – John Oliver
Ready for something that will blow your mind? The idea of using prediction markets in government (aka Futarchy; coined by Economist Robin Hanson) adds everything we don’t understand about politics to the wonderfully illustrative quote above. Simply put, we’re describing a new form of government. In “futarchy,” we would vote on values, but bet on beliefs. Elected representatives would formally define and manage an after-the-fact measurement of national welfare, while market speculators would say which policies they expect to raise national welfare.
In crypto, MetaDAO has been trying it for key governance decisions for about a year now and has signed up other DAOs as well. Describing DAO governance as a market-governed civilization. Watch a short video here from Solana Breakpoint to get the gist.
Here’s a decision process:
A school is deciding between two options for improving student grades:
- Option A: Give students more homework.
- Option B: Give students less homework but make it harder.
Now, instead of just letting the principal or teachers pick the option, the school sets up a betting market. People can place bets on which option will improve grades the most.
So, here’s how the betting would work:
- Some people might bet that Option A (more homework) will raise average grades.
- Others might bet that Option B (less homework but harder) will raise average grades.
At the end of the semester, the school will check which option actually worked better by measuring how much grades improved. The people who bet on the option that improved grades the most win their bets and make money. The people who bet on the option that didn’t work as well lose their bets.
This way, the school doesn’t just guess which option is better; it lets people who are confident they know what will work bet on it. And the option with the most confident bets is the one the school chooses.
And yes, I can hear you screaming at the screen! You’re absolutely right—there is always a risk that the option not chosen might have been better. But futarchy tries to minimize that risk by letting people who have strong knowledge or insights put their money on the line. And this encourages more informed decision-making. A very good thing.
We’re not there yet. And while prediction markets are having a memetic moment during this US presidential election cycle, the real question is can they break out of their more traditional and long-running role as an interesting concept without product market fit at scale? See, I told you you’d finish this article.
Project Spotlight
Dexalot
Dexalot launched on Base in August and integrated with the DEX aggregator Paraswap. It surpassed 100M transactions and reached an all-time high of $215M in daily trading volume. The team revised trading fees, lowering default maker and taker fees on all pairs from 0.20%/0.30% to 0.10%/0.12%, with stable pairs unchanged, and introduced volume-based discount tiers with additional discounts for ALOT holders. The Dexalot Incentive Program (DIP), which allocates approximately $200k worth of ALOT monthly to market makers, was extended for another year. Additionally, the Dexalot subnet evolved into Dexalot L1, distributing pre-launch incentives to testnet users. With the latest jump in traction and volumes, the CLOB DEX looks primed to capture on-chain activity in the coming quarters. The token price has been consolidating well currently, and the team is now working on exchange listings to get more distribution for the token.
MARKET NEWS
- BRICS Summit 2024 focused on de-dollarization using CBDCs and blockchain-based BRICS Pay as a payment solution. Russian, Chinese, and Iranian leaders pushed for a new financial system through crypto and digital platforms.
- There are conflicting opinions on what the impact of each candidate in the US presidential election would have on crypto markets. Bloomberg reported that Bitcoin would do well regardless of who wins; Citi however said Trump winning would be most bullish, with Harris’s win leading to uncertainty.
- There was a lot of debate around the role of prediction markets in accurately predicting the outcome of the US presidential election and the heavy effect of whales in such markets.
- A subcommittee of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (CFTC) Global Markets Advisory Committee voted to approve guidelines for using tokenized shares of money-market funds as collateral for traditional financial operations.
- Payments giant Stripe announced the acquisition of stablecoin platform Bridge for a reported $1.1 billion. The acquisition is subject to regulatory approval and is expected to close in the coming months.
- The AI bot Terminal of Truths on X popularized the GOAT memecoin, which saw its market cap soar from $3 million to about $800 million, driven by social media interactions and the bot’s endorsements.
- Uniswap announced plans to launch its own Layer-2 network, Unichain, built on the Optimism Superchain.
- Avalanche-based ‘Off the Grid’, a battle royale game that features loot box extraction mechanics, became the top performer among the free-to-play options in Epic Games’ store, one of the largest game markets.
- Kraken is planning to launch its own Ethereum Layer 2 blockchain called “Ink” early next year, following the lead of rival crypto exchange Coinbase.
- Shigeru Ishiba, Japan’s next Prime Minister and the newly elected head of Japan’s ruling Liberal Democratic Party, revealed pro-blockchain and NFT policies. Ishiba thinks blockchain and NFTs can help boost regional economies.
If this newsletter was forwarded to you and would like to receive it directly in your inbox, sign up here.
Questions? Feedback? We’d love to hear from you! Simply reach out to us at contact@woodstockfund.com
Warm Regards,
Adam Mastrelli
Woodstock Team