December 2023

Key Insight for this Month in Digital Assets: 2023 Year End Newsletter

2023 was a year where digital assets were mostly forgotten in the mainstream however the ecosystem was aggressively building and on-chain activity continued to edge higher all through the year, across multiple chains. 

The dichotomy between building an ecosystem and mainstream adoption makes for a very interesting 2024 where we anticipate that many non-believers will be quite surprised when news starts seeping back into the mainstream.

Typically, at this time of the year, predictions are made for the next 12 months. To do this slightly differently and to keep the discussion broader we have tried to take a simpler Q&A approach to answer some queries that we have received in the last quarter from our LPs, founders, or even families. 

Please note that none of this should be construed as financial advice.

  1. What are the key takeaways from 2023?
  • No entity is out of reach for the regulators and the law: This was seen in the SEC settlement against Binance. It strongly proves our conviction that regulation is here to stay and is a net positive for the industry.
  • The Layer 1 battle isn’t over: While it felt that Ethereum (L1+L2s) was running away with the mindshare, Solana made a very strong comeback and has started flirting with Ethereum on both DEX and NFT volumes. Other ecosystems such as Avalanche, Near, and Cosmos have also been generating significantly higher transactions and DAUs. This again is in line with our thesis that the future is multi-chain.
  • We need more applications: The infrastructure is significantly better than the last cycle and we are in the phase where clear winners will start emerging and consolidation will start occurring across various sectors. While the largest use case for the ecosystem today is speculation, the infrastructure is now ready to start hosting applications of other types of use cases. Users will eventually be attracted to applications, not infrastructure.
  • Blockchain can go vertical AND horizontal: While we have been building a vertical stack based on blockchain technology and decentralization, we are noticing that the technology can overlap with other sectors as well, such as AI, Physical Infrastructure Networks, Real World Assets, etc. This was clearly outlined in our thesis under “convergence”.
  1. What will be the price of Bitcoin in 2024? What are the key tailwinds?

Rather than answering this with a price prediction we would like to point out the tailwinds that could strongly work in the favour of Bitcoin in 2024:

  • Bitcoin ETF approval and launch: Galaxy Digital believes that Bitcoin ETFs could bring $14Bn of fresh institutional capital into the asset class in the first year, spiking up to over $38Bn in year 3. 
  • Bitcoin halving: The rewards released to the miners halves every 4 years and this is expected to happen again in early Q2 2024 when block rewards reduce from 6.25 BTC per block to 3.125 BTC per block. Historically, this has been a positive event for price action as the supply shrinks and a higher price is expected to keep the $ rewards identical for the miners.
  • Rate cuts: The treasury yield curve has sold off significantly (100 bps+) in the longer durations over the last couple of months. Current pricing indicates 3-4 price cuts in 2024 which is again bullish for risk and growth assets. With the US elections in Nov 2024, the Government will be motivated to ensure that the public sentiment is positive leading up to the elections.
  • Ordinals and BRC20: While this is quite recent ordinals and BRC20 have invigorated a lot of demand for Bitcoin blockspace, increasing the transaction fees generated on the network. While this may not be appreciated by the Bitcoin core community who have always wanted to keep Bitcoin free from jpegs and memes etc, it could make the chain a lot more resilient by creating an alternate source of income for miners who are otherwise mostly reliant on the mining rewards, which halves in April this year. 

A strong Bitcoin price action bodes well for the rest of the market as it is the largest asset, brings the most eyeballs, and capital flows down the curve once Bitcoin performs well. While the asset class now has many more mature ecosystems, Bitcoin performance is still a good benchmark to follow.

  1. What are the downside risks to digital assets in 2024?

The key downside risks to digital assets in 2024 are:

  • Rejection of Bitcoin ETF: This could create a cascade of liquidations as the market started its upward trajectory with the bullishness around the approval of the ETF. While a rejection appears unlikely now, it is still a risk, and the nature of the ETF (cash/kind, limits, etc) will also be a factor in determining how much capital flows into it.
  • Recession: While the economy remained resilient in the face of rate hikes, we need to stay cautious especially as covid perks to retail dissipate and corporates come back to raise in a higher rate environment. A recession could bring about a sharp pullback in the asset class. However, it will also almost certainly be accompanied by significant rate cuts and quantitative easing (or money printing) which should help digital assets bounce back. 
  • Coordinated regulatory crackdown: Highly unlikely as multiple jurisdictions have embraced the future with digital assets – notable being UAE, Hongkong, and the UK. This is also an election year in pivotal democracies like the US and India and policy priorities will likely shift away from digital assets.
  • Implosion or hack of a major player: We have again started seeing nascent products attracting large amounts of capital from users, in search of higher yields. We also know that a lot of chains, especially L2s, are operating in a centralised manner. All of this leaves room for a major implosion or hack compromising large amounts of capital. However as was seen in the implosions in 2022 the market is quite resilient and bounces back from such disappointments in a strong manner.

As we had covered in our previous newsletter, the ecosystem has sufficient activity and capital and should easily be able to withstand any sharp pullbacks.

  1. What chains do you anticipate having the most activity in 2024?

The chains that show the most activity will be the ones that have a) strong narratives and backers, b) treasury capital and access to fresh capital, c) have demonstrated strong activity in the past. 

Essentially, they should be moving from a ‘Fat Protocol’ to a ‘Fat Applications’ zone whereby the market value of all the applications built on top of the protocol is increasing at a faster rate than the protocol’s market value.

  • Ethereum: Still the ‘top dog’ in terms of activity and on-chain capital. The launch of Eigen Layer, Dencun and Prague updates, L2 token launches, and inevitable talk of Ethereum ETF post Bitcoin ETF approval, are all strong tailwinds for Ethereum (L1) to maintain its supremacy.
  • Optimistic roll-up L2s (Arbitrum and Optimism): L2s should be orders of magnitude faster and cheaper than Ethereum L1, and other L1s as well. While ZK roll-ups arguably will be the end state from that standpoint, their economies of scale require significantly more transactions. Therefore, at the moment, Optimistic roll-ups are much cheaper and therefore attract most of the L2 activity. We don’t anticipate this changing in 2024.
  • Solana: What Solana has achieved in 2023 is extraordinary and they now have the momentum and the critical mass to continue thriving in 2024 as well. 

There are a couple more blockchains that have the capital and the community (Near, Avalanche) that need to work on creating the appropriate differentiation and narratives to thrive on a consistent basis.

  1. What sectors are you expecting to outperform in 2024?

In no particular order,

  • GameFi: With hundreds of Web3 games expected to launch in 2024, including many AAA games, gaming will be one of the hottest sectors in crypto which could onboard tens of millions (if not hundreds) of new users. While a lot of the games may not survive (success rates of traditional games are also extremely poor), a new set of users may become enamored with digital assets. Some leading examples include Shrapnel and Crown.
  • GambleFi: As speculation is currently the largest use case of digital assets and the on-chain technology and UX have significantly improved in the last few years, gambling and prediction-based projects such as Rollbit could do extremely well if they are able to plan their GTM well. They will potential face regulatory crackdown in the long term and licenses may be difficult but short to medium-term alpha and degen opportunities could be considerable.
  • Re-Staking and therefore Liquid Staking: The launch of EigenLayer is highly anticipated and this could be yet another Lido moment for Ethereum. It could also kick start another DeFi wave on Ethereum as many liquid yield strategy protocols are already getting built on top of EigenLayer and will offer enhanced yields to stakers (ETH staking yield + Re-staking AVS Rewards + Liquid Restaking protocol rewards + Potential EigenLayer farming rewards).
  • Middleware (consolidation into Top 2): The middleware infrastructure layer will emerge as one of the key winners in serving the entire universe of L1s, L2s, rollups, and appchains. Covalent (indexing and long-term data availability), Chainlink (oracle and cross-chain interoperability protocol), and Biconomy (account abstraction) are well poised to emerge as leaders in these categories, and further consolidate their positions in 2024.
  1. What sectors are you expecting to underperform in 2024?

Again, in no particular order:

  • RWA: Most of the RWA TVL is based on bringing US treasuries on-chain which is attractive considering that these treasuries yield 5%+ and DeFi yields have been poor. As the market turns, DeFi activity increases, the Fed cuts rates and US Treasury yields shrink, we anticipate the capital to move away from RWA.
  • ZK Roll-ups: L2s built on ZK technology lag behind their Optimistic roll-up peers who have been in the market for much longer and have gathered significantly higher user base and capital. The key issue with ZK roll-ups from a user perspective is that it is still much more expensive than their Optimistic counterparts. While this will be solved with higher volume and tech upgrades, we don’t anticipate that happening in 2024.
  • Creator-based NFTs: While NFTs can be programmed to include royalties for artists and creators, the speculative nature of the asset and the user base has made royalties almost obsolete. While we may see royalties back in some fashion, the previous experience will have put off a lot of creators. 
  1. How do you think Founders should prepare for and navigate 2024?
  • Continue building!
  • We are at another inflection point for our industry and the next wave may bring 10s to 100s of millions of users. Focus and strategize on how you will be in the top 2-3 of your category to attract this user base directly or indirectly.
  • Whether you are user or developer-focused, you need to be a 10x improvement on the incumbents across Web3 and Web2.
  • While the funding landscape is still far from what we saw in 2021/22, it has eased up in the last couple of quarters. The worst appears to be behind us but exercise caution with burn and begin fundraising with at least 9-12 months of runway.
  1. Do you see retail and LP sentiment returning to digital assets?

Yes, definitely. In our recent travels, it has surprised us that traditional funds and people outside of the ecosystem are completely oblivious to the developments. It appears that the unfortunate episodes of 2022 (Terra, Alameda/FTX, etc) have had a psychological and possibly economic impact on a lot of players. It is therefore understandable that they are mentally disconnected from the ecosystem.

However, price action and positive regulatory movements (Bitcoin ETF approval, Binance sanctioning, etc) will not only instill some confidence back but also provide deeper legitimacy to the asset class. As such, retail and traditional LPs would start looking back at the asset class in due course. Economically, it still provides one of the best alpha opportunities across the spectrum.

Project Spotlight

NEAR Protocol

In 2023, despite market challenges, NEAR achieved significant milestones. With four of the top ten Web3 apps, including Sweat Economy and PlayEmber, NEAR witnessed a remarkable 8x growth, totalling 7 million monthly active accounts. The ecosystem strengthened its alignment with Ethereum, collaborating on solutions like NEAR DA and fast finality (with EigenLayer) for rollups, and partnering with Polygon on zkWASM.

The Blockchain Operating System (BOS) was launched, providing a decentralized stack for builders across networks, featuring fast onboarding and composability with over 15k forkable components. The year also saw the release of technologies enabling chain abstraction, such as FastAuth for quick onboarding and NEAR QueryAPI for efficient blockchain indexing.

As the NEAR Foundation focuses on 2024, the emphasis will be on chain abstraction, account aggregation, and user-owned AI. Chain abstraction aims to make blockchain infrastructure invisible to users, tackling a major adoption barrier. Account aggregation, facilitated by Pagoda (the engineering arm), will enable users to transact seamlessly across blockchains with a non-custodial, Web3-centric account. Additionally, the protocol will launch Phase 2 of sharding, enhancing performance and decentralization.

Market News

  • Woodstock Fund attended the Indian Blockchain Week and ETH India. We held a gathering along with our portfolio companies Arcana Network, Biconomy, Transak, and Push Protocol. Our General Partner, Pranav Sharma, moderated a panel on “Bollywood in Metaverse”, and our Partner, Prashanth Swaminathan, also spoke at a panel on “L1/L2 Ecosystems” at the Web3 Carnival.
  • US Partner, Adam Mastrelli, was a speaker at the Milken Institute Middle East & Africa Summit in Abu Dhabi. You can watch his session on the State of Venture Capital here.
  • Microstrategy, the largest corporate holder of Bitcoin, purchased an additional $615M of Bitcoin, increasing their total holdings to $5.9Bn
  • Connect Kit, a widely-used piece of blockchain software maintained by the crypto wallet firm Ledger, was exploited after hackers inserted malicious code into its GitHub library, after successfully targeting an employee through a phishing attack.
  • Tea, a decentralized technology protocol that enables open-source developers to be rewarded for their software contributions, launched an incentivised testnet.
  • Arcana Network, building web3 tooling and consumer products to enhance UX and adoption, successfully completed its public sale raise on the Republic platform.
  • Transak became the primary payment provider for Immutable, one of the leading Web3 gaming platforms. This will bring payments seamlessly to Immutable’s plethora of Web3 games.
  • Bitcoin’s hash rate, the gauge of the network’s computing power, hit an all-time high on Christmas day. 
  • The Indian government has issued compliance show cause notices to nine offshore crypto exchanges under its Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). 

If you were forwarded this newsletter and would like to receive it directly in your inbox, sign up here.

Questions? Feedback? We’d love to hear from you! Simply reach out to us at contact@woodstockfund.com

Warm Regards,

Woodstock Team

Leave a Reply

The information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and should not be construed to be investment advice or considered to be a recommendation of any particular security, strategy or investment product. No portion of this content should be construed as an offer or solicitation for the purchase or sale of any security or investment. An offering may be made available only to certain sophisticated investors through official delivery of confidential offer documents along with other documents. Readers must understand that past performance is not a guarantee of future results.